The Divine Paradox: Love and Justice in Perfect Balance

Mark O'Reilly
Nov 25, 2024By Mark O'Reilly

Dear Reader,

Tonight I can't sleep. I've been lying here, thinking about those verses I've known since childhood - John 3:16 and 2 Corinthians 5:21. But somehow, tonight, they're hitting differently. It's like I'm seeing them with new eyes.

I keep turning this thought over in my mind: What if God had chosen to just love without being righteous? He could have just waved His hand and said, "Don't worry about it - all is forgiven." No cross needed. No suffering. No sacrifice. It would have been easier, wouldn't it?

But something deep inside me knows that wouldn't have been enough. It's like... if my parent just overlooked everything wrong I ever did, would that really be love? Or would it be a kind of neglect? Sometimes love has to be tough to be real.

I think that's what's keeping me awake tonight - this stunning realization that when sin entered the world, it wasn't just about breaking rules. It was like everything got knocked out of alignment. God's perfect order, His glory, His holiness - all of it was affected. It reminds me of that time my computer got a virus - everything was corrupted, and no amount of "ignoring the problem" was going to fix it.

What amazes me is how God solved this impossible puzzle. He couldn't just be merciful and ignore justice - that would deny who He is. He couldn't just be righteous and condemn us all - that would deny His love. So what did He do? He took the judgment Himself. It's beautiful and heartbreaking at the same time.

I'm sitting here thinking about Jesus, carrying all that weight. The perfect One becoming sin. It's mind-bending. Not just taking our punishment, but actually becoming sin for us. And in exchange, we get His righteousness? It seems too good to be true, yet it's the truest thing there is.

Sometimes I wonder if we've made Christianity too complicated. Tonight it seems so clear: Love had to find a way to be both kind and just. And it did - on a cross where God himself bore the weight of every wrong thing ever done. Not because He had to, but because that's who He is - perfectly loving, perfectly just.

The clock says it's 3 AM now. But I needed to write this down. Tonight these ancient truths feel new again. God's love isn't soft or sentimental - it's as fierce as justice itself. And His justice isn't cold or cruel - it's as warm as love itself. Somehow, in Jesus, they come together perfectly.

I think I understand better now why John Newton wrote "Amazing Grace." Because this is amazing - that the Judge would take the punishment, that Love would bear justice's weight, that God would become sin so I could become righteous.

Maybe later today these thoughts won't feel as profound as they do right now in the quiet of early morning. But I don't think I'll ever look at a cross the same way again. It's not just a symbol of sacrifice - it's the place where love and justice met and kissed, where God found a way to be both completely righteous and completely loving.

Time to try to sleep again. But I'm glad I wrote this down. Some revelations are too precious to trust to memory alone.

Until tomorrow, Chaplain Mark